Virtual reception

Review of appeals: 2022

2,234
Appeals received

−54.4% (2021: 4,901)

2,219
Considered

Under consideration: 15

88
Resolved positively
817
Satisfied through legal advice and explanations

Summary of the review

The Anti-Corruption Agency of the Republic of Uzbekistan carries out a wide range of activities aimed at protecting the rights, freedoms and legitimate interests of individuals and legal entities, establishing communication with the population, bringing the work with appeals to a qualitatively new level.

In 2022, the Anti-Corruption Agency received 2,234 appeals. Consideration of 2,219 appeals has been ensured and 15 appeals are currently under consideration. Of these, 88 appeals were positively resolved, 817 appeals were satisfied by providing legal advice and clarifications. The Agency received a message of thanks for the positive solution of two appeals. 63 appeals were identified anonymous, consideration of 26 repeated appeals was completed in accordance with the established procedure. Information on 5 appeals was taken into account, 1,220 appeals were sent to the relevant ministries and departments.

Of the total number of appeals, 1,919 were received from individuals, 315 from legal entities, 1,565 in writing, 306 in electronic form, 363 in oral form, of which 103 appeals were received during a personal reception by the Director of the Agency, 75 appeals during meetings with specialists of the Agency, and 185 appeals were received through the Call-center.

Based on the results of consideration of appeals, the Agency submitted 52 enquiries to the relevant ministries and departments, as well as the regional (district, city) administrations, and 36 statutory notices submitted to eliminate violations.

Based on the results of consideration of appeals, 13 documents issued in violation of the law were annulled, and based on the documents submitted by the Agency, law enforcement agencies initiated 12 criminal cases, 5 cases of administrative liability and 12 cases of disciplinary liability, as well as measures were taken to eliminate the mistakes and shortcomings. Consideration of appeals revealed the financial errors in the amount of 30.9 billion soums.

Following the large-scale reforms carried out in Uzbekistan, and the practical work carried out by the Anti-Corruption Agency, including anti-corruption projects in various areas, the implementation of Roadmaps aimed at preventing corruption, and amendments to legislation, there has been a decrease in the number of appeals coming to the Agency. In particular, compared with 2,234 in 2022, in 2021 the Agency received 4,901 appeals, which in percentage terms means a decrease of 54.4 percent.

Most appeals are related to the judicial and legal area, the inappropriate actions of officials, and corruption in various areas.

Outcomes

Number of appeals by outcome. The bar helps compare the values.

Outcomes, 2022
OutcomeAppealsComparison
Resolved positively88
— of which the Agency received thanks2
Satisfied through legal advice and explanations817
Found anonymous63
Consideration of repeated appeals closed26
Taken for information5
Forwarded to the competent ministries and agencies1,220

Applicants and forms of appeal

Who applied

1,919
From individuals
315
From legal entities

How appeals were filed

1,565
In writing
306
Electronically
363
Orally

of which at personal reception by the Agency’s management: 103

of which at reception by responsible staff: 75

of which via the call centre: 185

Action taken

Following the study of appeals.

52
Enquiries to ministries, agencies and khokimiyats
36
Submissions to remedy violations of the law
13
Documents issued in breach of the law annulled
12
Criminal cases opened
5
Administrative liability cases
12
Disciplinary liability cases
30.9
Financial errors and shortcomings found, bn soums

Appeals by sector

The ten most frequent subjects. The full list is below the table.

Appeals by sector, 2022
Sector, subjectAppealsShareComparison
Complaints against court decisions22910.2%
Complaints about the inappropriate actions of employees in education sector and violations of legislation in the field1848.0%
Facts of violations of the law in the course of public procurement and tendering1607.0%
Complaints against inappropriate actions and decisions of law enforcement officers1345.8%
On the issue of employment with the Agency1225.8%
Complaints against the decisions of the Prosecutor’s Office and the lack of results regarding the consideration of appeals by the Prosecutor’s Office1144.9%
Complaints against the inappropriate actions of the heads of certain economic management bodies1115.3%
Complaints about unlawful actions and decisions of local administrations and officials1115.1%
Complaints regarding allocation of land plots, land disputes and theft of land plots1105.1%
Complaints about the inappropriate actions of medical workers and violations of legislation in the field of healthcare954.0%
All sectors and subjects (45)
All sectors and subjects (45)
Sector, subjectAppealsShare
Complaints against court decisions22910.2%
— Regarding decisions of courts in criminal cases120
— Regarding decisions of courts in civil cases59
— Regarding decisions of economic courts24
— Regarding decisions of administrative courts20
— Regarding decisions of military courts6
Complaints about the inappropriate actions of employees in education sector and violations of legislation in the field1848.0%
— In the field of public education944.2%
— In higher education482.1%
— In preschool education421.9%
Facts of violations of the law in the course of public procurement and tendering1607.0%
Complaints against inappropriate actions and decisions of law enforcement officers1345.8%
On the issue of employment with the Agency1225.8%
Complaints against the decisions of the Prosecutor’s Office and the lack of results regarding the consideration of appeals by the Prosecutor’s Office1144.9%
Complaints against the inappropriate actions of the heads of certain economic management bodies1115.3%
Complaints about unlawful actions and decisions of local administrations and officials1115.1%
Complaints regarding allocation of land plots, land disputes and theft of land plots1105.1%
Complaints about the inappropriate actions of medical workers and violations of legislation in the field of healthcare954.0%
Complaints on the fact of fraud753.9%
Appeals with proposals for improving legislation723.9%
Complaints about the actions of BCE employees and non-execution of executive documents703.2%
Appeals regarding loans and complaints about the inappropriate actions of bank employees703.2%
Complaints against the inappropriate actions of public administration employees562.6%
On entrepreneurship582.5%
Complaints against the inappropriate actions of chairs and workers of citizens’ assemblies452.1%
Appeals on the gas issue361.6%
On violation of labor legislation351.3%
Complaints about illegal construction341.6%
Appeals on cadastral issues231.1%
On housing and communal services221.0%
On making an appointment for a personal reception with the Director of the Agency200.9%
Appeals for recovery of compensation to victims of natural disasters190.9%
On the issue of non-compliance with the terms of the contract190.8%
On electricity issues170.7%
Complaints against the inappropriate actions of tax service employees150.7%
On the issue of embezzlement of budgetary funds150.7%
Regarding elections in mahallas (communities)130.6%
On issues of material assistance and recovery of material damage130.6%
On the pension issues100.5%
Appeals regarding joining an independent expert group that carries out a rating assessment80.4%
Complaints against the inappropriate actions of justice officials80.4%
Appeals on cases of violations in sports80.3%
Appeals about dissatisfaction with the lawyer’s actions70.3%
On issues related to the Prosperous Community Program70.2%
On the activities of associations of private homeowners60.3%
Appeals regarding corruption crimes60.3%
On the road management and transport60.2%
On the issue of collecting alimony50.3%
On work with youth41.0%
On the allocation of subsidies40.2%
On the issue of water supply20.2%
On environmental issues20.1%
Other issues542.6%

Appeals by region

Number of appeals from each region.

Appeals by region, 2022
RegionAppealsComparison
Tashkent city668
Tashkent region260
Kashkadarya region200
Samarkand region165
Namangan region132
Fergana region128
Bukhara region100
Surkhandarya region95
Andijan region93
Navoi region89
Jizzakh region83
Syrdarya region78
Khorezm region68
Republic of Karakalpakstan67
From abroad8

Conclusions and measures

Taking into account the fact that in the fight against corruption it is important to eliminate the factors causing corruption indicated in the appeals, to find ways to solve problems, to develop proposals for further improvement of legislation based on the analysis of the appeals, and to determine appropriate measures, the Anti-Corruption Agency approved the Action Plan 2022.

According to the Plan, the Agency developed draft regulatory acts on introducing amendments and additions to the current legislation, and submitted them to the relevant authorities.

In particular, considering that the current legislation does not specify the tasks and powers of the procurement commission, as well as the presence of a number of other corruption factors leading to a large number of requests regarding tenders, the Agency conducted expertise of the regulatory acts in the field of construction, during which 11 corruption risks were identified. In accordance with the proposals made by the Agency aimed at eliminating these corruption risks, the Regulation ‘On the procedure for organizing and implementing electronic public procurement in the construction sector’ was adopted, approved by the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of the Republic of Uzbekistan No. 46 of January 31, 2022.

Also, the Agency, together with ministries and departments, developed proposals for solving problems, changing existing procedures (digitization, simplification, termination, etc.) and further improving legislation by analyzing corruption situations and the factors that cause them, indicated in the appeals of citizens and legal entities, which were discussed at a meeting of the National Anti-Corruption Council, which approved the corresponding Roadmap. This Roadmap was submitted to the relevant ministries and departments for implementation.

In particular, taking into account the presence of a human factor when concluding an agreement on the creation of a nongovernmental preschool educational organization on the basis of public-private partnership, the Roadmap provides for the electronic signing of the agreement. To date, the Ministry of Preschool Education has taken appropriate measures and established the practice of electronic signing of agreements.

All appeal reports