Review of appeals: Q1 2022
−64% (Q1 2021: 1,543)
Under consideration: 67
Summary of the review
The Anti-Corruption Agency of the Republic of Uzbekistan is carrying out large-scale work aimed at protecting the rights, freedoms and legitimate interests of individuals and legal entities, establishing a dialogue with the population, as well as bringing the work with appeals to a qualitatively new level.
In particular, in the first quarter of 2022, the Anti-Corruption Agency received a total of 555 appeals, of which 488 were considered, and 67 appeals are currently under consideration. 9 of the appeals considered were resolved positively, 157 appeals were satisfied in the course of legal consultations and clarifications, 18 appeals were declared anonymous, 4 duplicated appeals were terminated in the prescribed manner, 1 appeal was taken into account, 299 appeals were sent to the relevant ministries and departments under their jurisdiction.
Of the appeals received, 488 were received from individuals, 67 from legal entities, 401 appeals were in writing, 92 in electronic form, 62 in oral form, of which 37 appeals were received during a personal reception of the Agency’s Director, 21 appeal were accepted by the responsible officers of the Agency and 4 appeals through call center.
Based on the results of consideration of appeals, 38 enquiries were sent to the relevant ministries and departments, regional (district, city) administrations, 6 statutory notices were sent to eliminate violations.
Based on the results of consideration of appeals, one document issued in violation of the law was annulled, according to the documents provided by the Agency, law enforcement agencies initiated four criminal cases and one case of disciplinary liability, and measures were taken to eliminate existing shortcomings. The amount of financial errors and omissions identified in the study of appeals amounted to 30.3 billion soums.
Most of the appeals received by the Agency relate to problems in the judicial and legal sector, the misconduct of officials and corruption in various areas.
As a result of large-scale reforms in the country and the practical work carried out by the Anti-Corruption Agency, including the implementation of anti-corruption projects in various areas and roadmaps to prevent corruption, as well as inctroducing amendments to legislation, there is a decrease in the number of appeals received by the Agency, also in the context of industries.
In particular, compared to 1,543 appeals received by the Agency in the first quarter of 2021 and 555 appeals in the first quarter of 2022, the number of appeals in percentage terms decreased by 64%.
Outcomes
Number of appeals by outcome. The bar helps compare the values.
| Outcome | Appeals | Comparison |
|---|---|---|
| Resolved positively | 9 | |
| Satisfied through legal advice and explanations | 157 | |
| Found anonymous | 18 | |
| Consideration of repeated appeals closed | 4 | |
| Taken for information | 1 | |
| Forwarded to the competent ministries and agencies | 299 |
Applicants and forms of appeal
Who applied
How appeals were filed
of which at personal reception by the Agency’s management: 37
of which at reception by responsible staff: 21
of which via the call centre: 4
Action taken
Following the study of appeals.
Decrease by sector
How much the number of appeals fell compared with Q1 2021.
| Sector, subject | Change |
|---|---|
| Problems with granting of pensions and social benefits by | −83.3% |
| Violations of labor legislation by | −82.6% |
| Theft of budgetary funds by | −80.0% |
| Disagreement with court decisions in civil cases by | −78.2% |
| Problems with power supply by | −75.0% |
| In the field of cadastre by | −73.7% |
| Problems in housing and communal services by | −73.3% |
| In the field of public education by | −72.1% |
| Cases of violations in the field of healthcare and the misconduct of medical personnel by | −72.1% |
| Disagreement with the decisions of courts in criminal cases by | −68.3% |
| Disagreement with the the Compulsory Enforcement Bureau decisions by | −66.7% |
Growth in certain sectors
| Sector, subject | Change | Q1 2021 | Q1 2022 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Disagreement with the actions of employees of public administration bodies | +1200.0% | 1 | 13 |
| Issues of protecting the interests of business entities | +325.0% | 4 | 17 |
| Insurance issues | +100.0% | 0 | 1 |
| Disagreement with decisions of economic courts | +80.0% | 5 | 9 |
| Issues of recovery of compensation for damage from natural disasters | +46.2% | 13 | 19 |
| Preschool education issues | +10.0% | 10 | 11 |
Appeals by region
Number of appeals from each region.
| Region | Appeals | Comparison |
|---|---|---|
| Tashkent city | 159 | |
| Tashkent region | 51 | |
| Namangan region | 45 | |
| Syrdarya region | 41 | |
| Kashkadarya region | 35 | |
| Navoi region | 32 | |
| Samarkand region | 31 | |
| Surkhandarya region | 29 | |
| Andijan region | 26 | |
| Fergana region | 25 | |
| Bukhara region | 21 | |
| Jizzakh region | 20 | |
| Khorezm region | 19 | |
| Republic of Karakalpakstan | 19 | |
| From abroad | 2 |
Conclusions and measures
Also, compared to the first quarter of 2021, in the first quarter of 2022, there were no appeals in some areas and fields. In particular, in the first quarter of this year, there were no appeals on religion, ecology, obtaining a passport, or drinking water supply.
Compared with the first quarter of 2021, this year the number of appeals to the Agency from the regions decreased in the following order - from Surkhandarya Region by 80.8%, from Samarkand Region by 78.0%, from Khorezm Region by 75.9%, from Jizzakh Region75.9%, from Kashkadarya Region 74.5% and from Bukhara Region by 66.7%.
Considering the importance of fighting corruption, eliminating the factors that give rise to corruption, finding ways to solve problems, developing proposals for further improving legislation based on the analysis of appeals and identifying appropriate measures, the Anti-Corruption Agency approved the relevant Action Plan 2022.
According to this Plan, in 2022 it is planned to develop and submit to the relevant authorities draft regulatory legal acts on amendments and additions to the current legislation. In order to ensure the implementation of these tasks in the first quarter of this year, the Agency studied the relevant draft law on amendments and additions to the Criminal and Criminal Procedure Codes of the Republic of Uzbekistan as well as the practice of imposing certain types of punishment on persons convicted of corruption offenses, based which an appropriate draft law has been prepared.